Coastal Heritage Realty
Sunlit new-build kitchen with white cabinetry, a quartz island, natural wood accents and a view of a green fenced backyard in Callaway.

What a Brand-New House Costs in Callaway This Fall

November 19, 2026

At 5136 Elyse Way in Grand Oaks of Callaway, Century Complete is advertising a finished Beaumont plan with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, a 2-car garage and 1,416 square feet for $249,888. The listing says the house is ready to move into and is marked for closing-cost savings. The builder says prices ending in "888" have recently been cut.

That price is the most useful number for anyone shopping for houses for sale in Callaway, FL right now. Five other builder communities in the same ZIP code are asking within about $45,000 of it for their smallest homes. If you are comparing Callaway with Lynn Haven, Parker or east Panama City, start here. Any older 3-bedroom near Tyndall listed in the $250,000s or $280,000s is competing with a new house that comes with a builder warranty, a sales office open seven days a week and a promotion calendar.

The new-home price sheet in ZIP 32404

These are the entry points as advertised on builder pages in mid-November 2026. The prices are live inventory and change often, so treat them as a snapshot.

Community Builder Location Advertised "from" price Smallest listed home
Grand Oaks of Callaway Century Complete 5120 Elyse Way, Callaway $249,888 1,416 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba, $249,888
Park Place D.R. Horton 8350 Park Place Dr., Callaway $264,900 1,293 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba, $269,900
Liberty D.R. Horton 6225 Chapman Ln., 32404 $249,900 1,458 sq ft, 4 bd/2 ba, $269,900
Morningside D.R. Horton 7467 Morningside Dr., 32404 $269,900 1,427 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba, $269,900
Titus Park D.R. Horton 4924 Rosemary St., 32404 $294,900 1,637 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba, $294,900
Harvey Heights Holiday Builders 5175 Harvey St., 32404 $278,990 Homes from 1,516 sq ft

Divide each smallest listed home's price by its square footage and the new-construction band comes out between about $176 and $209 per square foot. Grand Oaks is the low end at roughly $176. Liberty's 4-bedroom on Merlyn Dethlefsen Road works out to about $185, Morningside's 3-bedroom on Delancey Street to about $189, and Park Place's 1,293-square-foot plan to about $209. Titus Park's starter home at 4913 Rosemary Street lands near $180. That band gives a buyer comparing an older home in the same ZIP code a concrete yardstick. A buyer already knows what a brand-new square foot costs a few streets away.

Location within 32404 still matters. D.R. Horton describes Liberty, off Highway 231 and Star Avenue, as 13 miles from Tyndall Air Force Base and Morningside as 17.5 miles from the base. Park Place and Grand Oaks carry Callaway locations. For a buyer whose commute ends at the Tyndall gate, that difference in mileage is part of the price.

Why the county numbers make that sheet matter more

The new-home floor would matter less if older homes were selling fast. Across Bay County they are not. In October 2026, the median days on market in Bay County was 104, essentially flat from October 2025, according to Realtor.com data published through the St. Louis Fed's FRED database. In the same month, the county's median listing price was $399,900, down 2.81% from a year earlier. Bay County had 2,740 active listings in October 2026, a count that includes condos and townhomes and leaves out pending sales.

On closed sales, the News Herald reported that Bay County's median sale price was $363,250 in July 2026, up from $360,000 in June. July was the latest month available when the paper published in late October.

Put those beside the price sheet. Grand Oaks' entry home is listed about $150,000 below October's county median listing price and about $113,000 below July's county median sale price. The county figures cover everything from Gulf-front condos to inland ranch homes, so this is not a like-for-like comparison. It does show where Callaway sits in Bay County. The ZIP code around Tyndall is where a buyer can get a new house for well under the county midpoint, and that pulls every older house in the same price range toward the builders' numbers.

The other October figure points the opposite way. Bay County had 484 new listings in October 2026, down 12.64% from October 2025. Fewer owners put homes on the market this fall than last fall. In Callaway that means resale supply is shrinking while builder supply grows, and new construction makes up a bigger share of what an entry-level buyer can choose from.

What an older 3-bedroom is up against

A resale seller sets a price once and usually waits. The builders change their terms on a calendar. This fall, Century Complete's North Florida offer advertised an appliance package plus closing-cost help, or special pricing, on select homes for buyers who signed by November 18 and closed by November 30, 2026. Its parent company, Century Communities, is advertising up to $30,000 off select homes for contracts signed November 16 through November 30, 2026. The promotion page does not say which communities are included. D.R. Horton's pages for Park Place, Liberty, Titus Park and Morningside advertise a Military Buyer Program and a limited-time opportunity on select homes, and some individual listings carry "Special Interest Rate" labels.

None of that makes a resale home a weaker purchase. Older homes in Callaway often have an established lot, a finished yard or a floor plan the builders no longer build. Those qualities carry a cost, though. A seller of a 1,400-square-foot house listed in the $260,000s is asking a buyer to give up a warranty, new systems and a builder incentive. The listing has to make up for that with price, condition or something the new subdivisions cannot match.

For a buyer, the price sheet changes the conversation. A buyer can point to a specific new house on Elyse Way or Lawton Branch Way, its price and its square footage when talking about an older home's list price. That is a stronger position than citing a county median, and in a county where the typical listing waits more than three months, sellers tend to listen.

Tyndall is a long timeline

Most buyers who look at Callaway are thinking about Tyndall, and the base is still being built. In a November 13, 2026 report by MyPanhandle, Tyndall's commander said Hangar One is the first of three F-35 hangars the base has taken ownership of, with the other two still to come. The same report said three facilities still need construction contracts and there is no exact completion date for the full rebuild, which will take several more years.

The base's own rebuild page lists a $4.5 billion investment and 120 new facilities, and dates the first F-35A arrival to August 2023. As of October 23, 2026, the base had opened a 60,000-square-foot Community Commons and the 360-room Sand Dollar Lodging facility.

Callaway has been approving homes with the base in mind for years. In February 2022, WMBB reported that the city had approved the 341-home Alexandra's Park and the 276-unit Callaway Bayou Townhomes. City Manager Eddie Cook told the station that Tyndall's rebuild was making the need for housing "almost critical." The News Herald placed Alexandra's Park on 77 acres north of James Street, west of the Callaway Sports Complex. Approvals have continued since. The Callaway City Commission approved the Still Waters Subdivision development order by a 4–1 vote on February 24, 2026.

Taken together, demand from Tyndall arrives a hangar at a time over years, and Callaway keeps approving supply to meet it. A buyer counting on the base to push resale prices up quickly is betting against that pattern. A buyer planning to own for the length of the rebuild has a clearer case: new construction around Callaway is priced well below the county midpoint today, and the base expects several more years of work.

Quick answers for Callaway shoppers

What is the lowest advertised price for a new house in Callaway right now?

In mid-November 2026, Century Complete's Grand Oaks of Callaway advertised homes from $249,888, including a move-in-ready 1,416-square-foot, 3-bedroom home at 5136 Elyse Way. D.R. Horton's Park Place in Callaway starts at $264,900.

How long are Bay County homes taking to sell?

The median listing in Bay County spent 104 days on the market in October 2026, about the same as October 2025, according to FRED's Realtor.com series.

When will the Tyndall rebuild be finished?

The base has given no exact completion date. As of November 13, 2026, its commander said the rebuild will take several more years, with two F-35 hangars and three facility contracts still ahead.

Builder prices and promotions here are as advertised in mid-November 2026 and change often. This post is general market information, not financial advice, so confirm any incentive or financing terms with the builder and your own lender. If you're weighing an older Callaway home against a new build on Elyse Way or Lawton Branch Way, Coastal Heritage Realty can go over both homes with you before you write an offer. Schedule Your Complimentary Consultation.

Ready to take the next step?

Buying or selling a home is a major milestone, and you deserve a team that truly listens and understands your needs. We take a personalized approach to every client, ensuring that your experience is smooth, stress-free, and successful.